The decline of the dollar does not guarantee a victory for Bitcoin.

33

The swift deterioration of the U.S. dollar has rekindled aspirations of “hyperbitcoinization” among Bitcoin supporters. However, there is scant evidence to suggest that the decline of the dollar equates to Bitcoin’s triumph; rather, there is substantial indication that it could lead to widespread disorder.

The dollar’s decline: insights from currency failure

Fernando Nikolic, former VP at Blockstream and a seasoned observer of Argentina’s financial crises, warns against Bitcoin enthusiasts who are eager for the demise of fiat:

“Bitcoiners celebrating dollar collapse don’t understand what they’re asking for… It’s not liberation, it’s your grandmother eating cat food because her savings evaporated… The dollar dying doesn’t make Bitcoin win.”

During genuine currency failures, essential items like ammunition (not digital currencies) become the only assets of true worth. Many Americans envisioning a swift shift to a Bitcoin-centric economy lack experience with real societal disintegration.

The truth, Nikolic cautions, is significantly more tumultuous than they comprehend, and they would not actually embrace the consequences of the dollar’s demise they are imagining.

A grim scenario across the U.S. indicates a strained fiat system

The American housing market has never been more unattainable. Median home prices reached unprecedented levels in 2025, necessitating double the income to purchase a single-family home compared to 2019.

The decline of the dollar does not guarantee a victory for Bitcoin.0US Home Price History: 1890 to 2025 (Source: Re:venture)

The price-to-income ratio is at a historic peak, making homeownership less achievable than ever, with millions of renters allocating between 30% and 50% of their income to housing.

The disparity between wages and escalating housing expenses means that most potential buyers are priced out, exacerbating social tension.

Compounding the issue, U.S. unemployment rose to 4.3% in August 2025, the highest level since late 2021, with broader underemployment at 8.1%. These statistics obscure the distress caused by a labor market that struggles to keep up with inflation or stagnant real wages.

In the context of rising unemployment and increasing home prices, the U.S. national debt surpassed $37 trillion in August 2025, more than double the nation’s total economic output.

Borrowing costs are escalating, with interest payments now exceeding even defense expenditures. Projections from the Congressional Budget Office indicate that the debt level reached this threshold five years earlier than anticipated, primarily due to pandemic-related borrowing and increased social spending.

Debt accumulation at $1 trillion every five months is not sustainable, posing a risk of upward pressure on rates and crowding out investment.

When fiat collapses, Bitcoin does not automatically prevail

The dollar index fell by over 10% against major currencies this year, marking the steepest decline since 1973. This drop is attributed to erratic economic policies, protectionism, and extensive tax reductions.

As the dollar weakens, import costs rise, diminishing purchasing power for everyday Americans, exacerbating inflation, and straining family finances. The depreciation further impacts housing, employment, and debt, intensifying systemic vulnerability.

All these stark indicators illustrate a bleak reality of the underlying structure of the American economy, widely regarded as a gauge for the global economy. If, arguably, one of the world’s strongest currencies is under pressure, what implications does that have for the entire fiat system?

While numerous Bitcoin proponents assert, “Bitcoin fixes this,” the concept of hyperbitcoinization (the belief that people will flock to Bitcoin when fiat fails) is a perilous illusion. It disregards historical context and social realities. When currencies fail, trust dissipates, and fundamental survival needs take precedence over abstract concepts.

Nikolic’s insights, grounded in Argentina’s fiat collapse, reveal aspirations for “liberation” as misguided: collapse results in poverty, instability, and hardship.

Financial turmoil impacts the most vulnerable the hardest, as social safety nets and market conventions disintegrate. Bitcoin may present an alternative to inflationary fiat, but the demise of the dollar will not usher in freedom, but rather disaster and suffering for the majority.

The post The dollar dying doesn’t make Bitcoin win appeared first on CryptoSlate.