Disclaimer: Information found on CryptoreNews is those of writers quoted. It does not represent the opinions of CryptoreNews on whether to sell, buy or hold any investments. You are advised to conduct your own research before making any investment decisions. Use provided information at your own risk.
CryptoreNews covers fintech, blockchain and Bitcoin bringing you the latest crypto news and analyses on the future of money.
The DC Circuit Court delivered a groundbreaking ruling yesterday, leading Grayscale Investments to a significant triumph in a development that has reverberated throughout the Bitcoin community. The ruling effectively overturned the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) earlier rejection of Grayscale’s ambitious Bitcoin spot ETF proposal. This legal milestone introduces a new chapter in the ongoing Bitcoin spot ETF narrative, prompting experts to speculate about upcoming timelines and unforeseen implications.
The Chief Policy Officer of the Blockchain Association, Jake Chervinsky, praised the importance of this landmark ruling, describing it as a “massive” advancement. He highlighted that it is quite rare for a federal circuit court to criticize the SEC for breaching the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). Chervinsky asserted, “The DC Circuit decisively rejected the SEC’s claim that Grayscale’s ETF proposal lacked the necessary safeguards against fraudulent activities and manipulative practices.”
Interestingly, the court did not mandate immediate approval of the proposal; rather, it initiated a thorough examination of Grayscale’s request, guided by its significant ruling. Chervinsky formulated two speculative scenarios that capture Wall Street’s attention as he explores the potential paths forward.
One notable scenario involves the SEC discovering yet another justification to deny the proposal, reflecting their deep-seated skepticism towards the cryptocurrency sector. Conversely, the SEC might perceive this as a somewhat graceful retreat from their anti-ETF position, particularly in light of increasing pressure from traditional financial institutions eager to enter the Bitcoin ETF market. This year has witnessed a surge of ETF proposals, especially from prominent firms like Blackrock, where Larry Fink’s substantial influence is evident. Legal experts speculate:
“The million-dollar question is whether the SEC is willing to endure this process again.” It is likely that another denial would lead to yet another lawsuit. My earnest recommendation to the SEC is to act promptly. “The clock is ticking.”
A veteran ETF analyst, James Seyffart from Bloomberg Intelligence, affirmed the ruling’s importance. “This ruling serves as a thorough rebuke of the SEC’s persistent pattern of rejecting Bitcoin ETF applications,” he stated. However, Seyffart underscored the court’s silence regarding specific timelines for the SEC’s subsequent actions.
Related Posts
“I anticipated a countdown of 45 or 60 days, but the court’s stance remains notably quiet on that matter,” Seyffart speculated. Nevertheless, he accurately noted the SEC’s 45-day window to request an en banc hearing—a setting where all 17 justices of the court participate, extending beyond the initial trio of panel judges.
Seyffart presented a binary perspective on the SEC’s potential actions to obstruct Bitcoin spot ETFs: a deliberate withdrawal of Bitcoin Futures ETF listings or a new series of denials, likely focused on custody or settlement concerns. These notions have been reiterated in the SEC’s Staff Accounting Bulletin 121 (SAB 121).
Adam Cochran, an experienced CEHV associate, added another layer of complexity to the timeline. He referenced the impending uncertainty, suggesting that the SEC’s decisions regarding six additional Bitcoin spot ETF filings will hinge on the balance. Bitwise initiates the countdown on September 1, followed by BlackRock and Fidelity on September 2. Cochran’s forecast was validated:
“Those anticipating a deluge of ETF approvals this Friday may face an unpleasant surprise.” We are likely looking at an approval timeline in the fall, potentially extending into November. Unless the SEC prepares for an appeal, we may have to wait until spring.”
In summary, the court’s impactful ruling signifies a substantial win for Grayscale and the cryptocurrency sector. However, this landmark victory does not ensure automatic approval for a Bitcoin spot ETF. The SEC stands at a critical juncture, facing challenging decisions influenced by a complex interplay of legal, political, and market dynamics.
BTC is valued at $27,466 at the time of this report, reflecting a 5.3% increase over the past 24 hours. The cryptocurrency landscape continues to evolve as the significant tension between innovation and regulation unfolds.
The post Court Decision Changes Bitcoin ETF Path Amid SEC Showdown appeared first on BitcoinWorld.
