Bitcoin ETFs show minimal reaction as BTC declines by 40%, according to Bloomberg’s Eric Balchunas.

17

Bitcoin has decreased by over 40% from its peak in October, yet investors in spot Bitcoin ETFs have withdrawn only 6.6% of their assets.

Latest developments: Investors in ETFs are demonstrating a surprising level of resilience during bitcoin’s recent decline. In a discussion on CoinDesk’s Markets Outlook, Eric Balchunas, Senior ETF Analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence, pointed out several significant data trends that reflect this steadiness:

  • Bitcoin has experienced a drop exceeding 40% from its recent peaks, a trend that typically unsettles retail-focused crypto markets.
  • During the same timeframe, merely 6.6% of Bitcoin ETF assets have been withdrawn.
  • “At present, the ETF investors have really shown their strength,” he noted.

Why ETF holders are holding: Balchunas posits that ETF investors are fundamentally different from traders who are native to crypto.

STORY CONTINUES BELOWDon’t miss another story.Subscribe to the Crypto Daybook Americas Newsletter today. See all newslettersSign me up

  • Numerous ETF purchasers view bitcoin as a 1%–2% “hot sauce” allocation within a mix of stocks and bonds, rather than as a primary investment.
  • Their overall investment portfolios have gained from robust equity markets, mitigating the psychological impact of crypto downturns.
  • ETF investors “tend to remain very steady,” Balchunas remarked, having experienced multiple market cycles with traditional assets.

The contrast with crypto natives: The same price decline can evoke vastly different feelings based on one’s level of investment exposure.

  • Investors with a heavy focus on bitcoin encounter what Balchunas described as “existential crisis mode.”
  • Traders utilizing leverage and long-term holders may be contributing more to the selling pressure compared to ETF investors.
  • “Volatility is the price of the returns,” Balchunas stated, highlighting that bitcoin has faced seven or eight comparable drawdowns historically.

Lessons from gold ETFs: Balchunas identifies similarities between bitcoin and gold as assets packaged in ETFs.

  • Gold ETFs experienced a decline of approximately 40% over six months around a decade ago, during which about one-third of their assets exited.
  • Despite this, gold ETFs eventually rebuilt their assets and currently manage roughly $160 billion.
  • Bitcoin ETFs briefly approached the size of gold ETFs prior to the recent market selloff, illustrating how asset flows can change over time.

What comes next: Ongoing volatility is expected; however, ETFs may solidify bitcoin’s role within traditional finance.

  • Balchunas indicated that bitcoin’s 17-year history reflects a pattern of recovering to new highs following significant downturns.
  • The structure of ETFs positions Bitcoin alongside stocks, bonds, and commodities in conventional portfolios.
  • “A selloff doesn’t signify the conclusion,” he remarked. “It merely indicates a selloff.”